Relative Dangers: lack of Breast Feeding versus Firearms


The disadvantages to infants, children, and adults of not being breastfed include:

Gastrointestinal Illness: At least 400 infants die annually in the US from diarrheal disease; an estimated 250-300 of these deaths are attributed to not being breastfed.
Respiratory Illness: Between 500 and 600 infants die annually in the US from acute respiratory disease attributed to not being breastfed. The risk of fatal or nonfatal respiratory infections is two- to five-fold higher among formula fed infants.
Otitis Media: Ear infections occur more frequently in infants who are not breastfed.
Bacteremia and Meningitis: There is a fourfold higher risk of bacteremia and meningitis among babies who are not breast-fed.
Juvenile Diabetes: More than 100 studies indicate that breast-feeding can delay or prevent the onset of diabetes in children.
Malignant Lymphomas: A six- to eight-fold increase in the risk for lymphomas among children younger than 15 years has been found in children who were not breastfed for at least 6 months.
Breast Cancer: Having been breastfed as a child reduces breast cancer risk in women over 40 by more than 25%.
Pediatric News 33(1):37, 1999

We found the above list at Lactations.com: Daily Inspiration for the Nursing Mother. Keep in mind that these are only physical problems as seen by doctors.

The emotional damage from not being breastfed is quite real, as well.

Compare the hundreds of babies who die annually from "not being breastfed," and those who develop diabetes, cancer, or other conditions later for the same reason, with this table showing the numbers of children under 10 who die from accidents in the U.S. annually:

Causes and Numbers of Accidental Deaths of Children Under Age 10 (1997)

1. Motor vehicle ------------- 1,783
2. Traffic ------------------- 1,626
3. Drowning ------------------   750
4. Suffocation ---------------   577
5. Residential fires ---------   570
6. Struck by or on something -    89
7. Falls ---------------------    87
8. Cycling -------------------    78
9. Poisoning -----------------    58
10. Firearms -----------------    48

This table, said to be CDC data, is from So you hate guns and think they're bad? by Anita K. Blair, at The Independent Women's Forum. Searching the CDC data is time-consuming, especially since much of their data is in the form of PDF files. I gave up on it before I was able to confirm the table above.

On the other hand, I CAN pass along a URL from the CDC for 10 Leading Causes of Death, United States 1993-95, which also shows firearms as a much smaller threat to children than most other causes of death. This CDC page is a huge, multi-layered spreadsheet, and is broken down by age groupings as well as causes of death. When looking at the numbers, keep in mind that THREE YEARS of data are being shown. This chart is in HTML, so you won't need to save the thing and bring up your Adobe Acrobat viewer to read it.


This page is http://www.paradise-paradigm.org/breastfeeding.htm

(c) 2002 by Glen Allport, except as noted